skip the i-GuideIllinois State UniversityAdmissions at Illinois StateAcademics at Illinois StateEvents at Illinois StateMap of Illinois StateIllinois State A to Z ListingIllinois State University Accessibility Information
Center for Teaching, Learning & Technology
CTLT Home >> Resources >> Ask CTLT

Ask CTLT

QUESTION: I have a tough time getting students to discuss in class. What effective classroom discussion strategies would you suggest trying?

ANSWER:
There are many reasons students resist participating in class discussion, and I imagine nearly every faculty member has met with some level of challenge on this topic. The first step towards impacting the effectiveness of classroom discussion is to define what we mean by the word “effective”. We need to identify our learning goals in the discussion activity and know what we consider a successful discussion. To be a useful learning tool, discussion must take students to a higher level of processing information, not just memorizing the text. Students must engage in an activity involving evaluating, applying, or problem solving information for greater understanding to occur. Discussion is a great way to practice what they are attempting to learn (and what we are attempting to teach!).

“Classroom discussion” can incorporate a number of approaches. Discussion can occur between two students or a classroom of 200 and still be effective. Careful planning of the learning process is the key. Facilitating effective discussion in the classroom depends in large part on your course goals, your students, and your comfort level with activities. Consider the following list of ideas:

  • Ask the right questions (motivating, deep thinking, relevant, pertinent to goals)
  • Allow time for thinking/writing before speaking
  • Spend more time early in semester allowing students to get to know each other
  • Use a variety of discussion formats (small/large group, planned/spontaneous)
  • Set discussion ground rules/expectations
  • Promote small talk before class or icebreaker activities that require all to speak
  • Use classroom space strategically when possible don‘t allow hiding spaces
  • Be aware of your own (non)verbal communication that may encourage/discourage discussion
  • Assign students to small discussion groups regularly
  • Assign questions before assigning the chapter reading
  • Problem-solve lack of discussion with the class
  • Don‘t call on the first people with hands up give others time to join in
  • Don’t answer student questions let the class respond
  • Use clickers and other technology, such as online chats, to encourage discussion
Finally, research has shown that calling on students randomly is not an effective means of promoting class discussion. Students focused on fear are not as open to learning.